You can now order online!
Our Selections
Cookie Boxes
Fresh-baked boxes made to order. Choose your flavor(s), pick your size, and we’ll handle the rest.
Simply Sweet Half Dozen (6)
A curated half dozen of our gourmet cookies, baked fresh to order. Choose one cookie flavor and enjoy six beautifully baked treats made with care and quality ingredients.
$28.00

The Bakers Dozen (12)
Twelve gourmet cookies, baked fresh and boxed with intention. Choose up to two cookie flavors for a perfectly balanced mix of comfort and indulgence.
$48.00

The Family Favorites Box (24)
A generous box of two dozen gourmet cookies, ideal for gatherings, gifting, or sharing with the whole family. Choose up to four cookie flavors for variety everyone will love.
$80.00

Brownie Boxes
Rich, Ooey Gooey brownies baked fresh to order and boxed to satisfy every chocolate craving.
The Fudge Fix Box (6)
Six rich, fudgy brownies baked fresh to order. Choose one brownie flavor and enjoy deep chocolate indulgence in every bite.
$32.00

The Brownie Lover's Dozen (12)
A full dozen of our decadent brownies, made fresh and packed with flavor. Perfect for true brownie lovers or special occasions. Choose two brownie flavors per box.
$60.00

The Brownie Crowd Box (24)
Two dozen decadent gooey brownies baked fresh for deep, chocolatey satisfaction. Perfect for events, gifting, or treating a crowd. Choose four brownie flavors per box.
$110.00

Cookie & Brownie Combo Boxes
The best of both worlds! Cookies + Brownies, boxed fresh and ready to share (or not).
Best of Both Worlds Box
Can’t decide? This box gives you the best of both. Includes 6 treats (one cookie choice and one brownie choice) baked fresh to order and boxed to perfection!
$28.00
The Crowd-Pleaser Combo
A balanced mix of our most-loved treats. Includes six cookies of two flavors and six brownies of two flavors, freshly baked and ready to impress.
$60.00
Sampler Box
Curated, chef’s-choice assortments with a set mix of favorites!
The Goodness Sampler Box
This sampler gives you a taste of Simplygoodness! Includes mini pound cakes, brownies, and layered bars. No substitutions needed.
$28.00
Cobbler Cookie Bars
Warm, layered cobbler-style cookie bars baked fresh and packed with rich, comforting flavor, one of our most loved treats!
Cobbler Cookie Bars
Four of our signature cobbler-style cookie bars, baked fresh and layered with rich, indulgent flavor. One of our most loved treats.
$34.00

Dessert Bars
Rich, layered dessert bars baked fresh and packed with indulgent flavor.
8-Layer Bars
Decadent layers of chocolate, coconut, and a buttery crunch in every bite. Rich, indulgent, and baked fresh to order.
$20.00

Mini Pound Cakes
Individually sized pound cakes made fresh to order—perfect for personal treats, gifts, or a little indulgence just for you. Available in packs only.
Lemony Lemon Pound Cakes
Since 1982 made with real butter, freshly squeezed lemons and time-honored baking. These mini bundt cakes deliver a lemon flavor that truly brings homeade back to the basics!
$22.00

Classic Cakes
Ohhh So Delicious Homemade cakes baked fresh to order, from rich pound cakes to classic favorites and custom creations for any occasion. All cakes are made fresh to order. Please allow advance notice for preparation.
Coffee Cake
A warm, comforting classic with a soft cake base and a sweet, crumbly topping. Perfect for mornings, brunch, or a simple treat with coffee.
$48.00

Pinapple Upside Down Cake
A nostalgic favorite featuring caramelized pineapple and a buttery, golden cake. Baked fresh and full of rich, sweet flavor in every slice.
$50.00

Lemon Pound Cake (10")
Bright, moist, and full of fresh lemon flavor, this classic pound cake is baked from scratch and finished with a light citrus glaze. Simple, refreshing, and perfect for any occasion.
$55.00

Vanilla Pound Cake (10")
A rich, buttery pound cake with a soft, tender crumb and classic vanilla flavor. Baked fresh to order, it’s a timeless favorite that pairs beautifully with any gathering.
$55.00

Pinapple Carrot Cake (10")
A rich, moist carrot cake layered with crushed pineapple and warm spices, finished with a smooth, creamy frosting. This full-size cake is perfect for celebrations and made to impress.
$110.00

Custom Cake (Inquiry Required)
Looking for something special? Custom cakes are available for birthdays, events, and celebrations. Contact us to discuss your vision, flavors, and design we’d love to bring it to life.
$0.00

Banana Bread Loaves
Moist, homemade banana bread loaves baked fresh to order, with your choice of add-ins for the perfect personalized touch.
Classic Banana Bread Loaf
A soft, moist banana bread loaf made from scratch and baked fresh to order. Includes one add-in. Additional add-ins available. ⭐ Most Popular: Banana Bread with Chocolate Chips or Walnuts
$36.00

Dessert Platters
A premium, ready-to-serve dessert platter featuring a curated selection of our most loved treats. Perfect for gatherings, celebrations, and special occasions. 48–72 hours notice required.
Premium Dessert Platter
An elevated assortment of our signature desserts, including gourmet cookies, rich brownies, cobbler cookie bars, and mini bundt cakes. Thoughtfully arranged and baked fresh to order, this platter is perfect for sharing and designed to impress. Selections are pre-arranged to ensure the best variety and presentation. 48–72 hours notice required.
$100.00

Add a Little Extra
Add-ons only single cookies, brownies, and extras to complete your box.
Add a Cookie
Add-on only. Available with the purchase of a box, cobbler bar pack, mini lemony pack, cake, loaf, or platter.
$0.00

Add a Brownie
Add-on only. Available with the purchase of a box, cobbler bar pack, mini lemony pack, cake, loaf, or platter.
$0.00

Add a Cobbler Bar
Add-on only. Available with the purchase of a box, cobbler bar pack, mini lemony pack, cake, loaf, or platter.
$0.00

Add an 8-Layer Bar
Add-on only. Available with the purchase of a box, cobbler bar pack, mini lemony pack, cake, loaf, or platter.
$5.50

Add a Lemony Lemon Mini
Add-on only. Available with the purchase of a box, cobbler bar pack, mini lemony pack, cake, loaf, or platter.
$7.00

